Is Bituing Walang Ningning really that bad?
I, by no means, want to start a fight but I chanced upon two articles (both from Inquirer) with negative write-ups about the recently concluded "sineserye" of ABS-CBN. While, Nestor Torre's article has some merit, how can one say about the other whose entire article is based on a single scene he saw on tv. But then again, to each his own. Sharing the articles here:
The Stretch Marks Show
NOW THAT “BITUING WALANG Ningning” has finally faded to black on our TV screens, we can more objectively and comprehensively evaluate its long run on ABS-CBN.
First conclusion: It’s downright amazing how the people behind the show were able to stretch its slim movie story into a months-long drama series, full of emotional highs and lows, dramatic twists and turns, and melodramatic tics and schticks at every turn.
The result of all that stretching was sometimes discombobulating, however. Characters ended up contradicting their initial nature, the struggle between good and evil became too ferocious for words, and performances were either insufficient or over-the-top.
Most insufficient of all was Sarah Geronimo’s portrayal of the series’ lead ingenue, Dorina. Sarah is a good singer, but she wasn’t able to make her character dramatically compelling and empathetic, opting instead to play her as a weeping victim practically from beginning to end.
At the other, over-the-top end, the show was able to do the seemingly impossible—make a bad actress out of the much-admired Amy Austria.
The fine thespian was cast as the mother of Dorina’s rival, Lavinia, and was required to do such dastardly things that believability flew out of the window.
Clash of the Copycats
But Angelika as the new Lavinia ... Now who’s the genius behind this casting?
Angelika is famous for ... RDL Products. She’s pert, pretty and perky in a show-biz kind of way, which means you can count on her to laugh her tinkly laugh whenever she’s asked the latest chismis about her, or her latest crushes, or, yes, her very challenging role as the new Cherie Gil in ABS-CBN’s sineserye, otherwise known as the network’s latest stab at scraping the bottom of the barrel.
So Angelika is supposed to be playing this high-flying, wildly successful singer who’s out to smite her upstart competitor with a glacial stare or, failing that, with the most famous putdown in Pinoy pop culture. I’ve no idea how that sabuyan ng tubig—or was it basagan ng baso?—played out in the TV version, but I can tell you this. Angelika as Lavinia, at least from what I saw briefly, is nothing but a second-rate, trying-hard, uh, girl.
Angelika, wherever you are, sue the casting idiot that got you into this stinky mess. That goes for you too, Sarah girl.
read the entire article
here!